"Will close its doors for good." That was how the owners of The Surf Restaurant, Bar and Beach Motel put it on social media, as the Florida Times-Union reported on Sept. 14. They set Sept. 20 as the last day at 3199 S. Fletcher Ave.
Most of the goodbyes looked back at wing nights and the deck. The more useful question for anyone who lives near the south end of the island is what the land becomes next. The answer on file so far is smaller than the zoning allows. The plan also faces a different street. On a parcel where the city's code would permit apartments, townhouses or a cluster of rentals, the concept asks for 13 detached pool homes, with the entrance on First Avenue. If it goes forward roughly as drawn, this stretch of South Fletcher loses a place open to anyone who walked in off the beach. A private street of single-family homes takes its place.
Seven Decades, and the Last Eight Years
The Surf's own website calls it a local favorite since 1957. County records put the oldest buildings on the site at 1959. Either way, it predates nearly everything else on the beachfront dining strip. Its busiest stretch is remembered as the 1990s into the 2000s, when weekly wing specials and live music with dancing on the outdoor deck brought in locals and visitors alike.
The owners did not blame one thing. In the statement quoted by News4JAX on Aug. 12, they listed heavy competition, soft consumer spending, cost inflation and the restaurant's own performance.
The competition part has a date attached. The Surf closed for about six months for a major renovation and reopened in June 2018. Later that year, Salt Life Food Shack broke ground at Main Beach Park and opened in December 2018. It is a two-story restaurant and beach bar with elevated ocean views. The Surf had just put money into its own building when a new kind of beachfront room opened up the road.
The motel's status shifted over the summer. When the closing was first announced in August, News4JAX reported that no closure of the adjacent motel had been announced. By mid-September, the Times-Union reported that the restaurant and the motel would both close.
What the Zoning Would Allow
The parcel covers 1.86 acres. It is owned by FLANSOUTH LLC, which bought it in 2016 for a recorded $1,662,000. It is zoned R-3, which the city's code calls High Density Residential.
The Fernandina Beach Land Development Code, revised May 5, 2026, describes R-3 as intended for high-density residential uses with both single- and multi-family dwellings. It says bed and breakfast inns and resort rental dwellings may be allowed, subject to additional design standards. The density table sets the district's ceiling at 10 dwelling units per gross acre.
Set against the concept plan, the numbers look like this:
| R-3 zoning, per the city code | "The Surf Residential" concept | |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum density | 10 units per gross acre | 13 homes on 1.86 acres, about 7 per acre |
| Unit count by simple math | About 18 on 1.86 acres, before other site standards | 13 |
| Housing types | Single-family detached, duplex, triplex, townhouse, multifamily with 4 or more units | Single-family detached only |
| Other uses the district can allow | Bed and breakfast inns, resort rental dwellings with added design standards | None shown |
| Home size | Not set by the density table | Roughly 1,400 to 1,800 square feet |
The 18-unit figure is only the gross density multiplied out. Setbacks, parking, stormwater and the city's other standards would all shape what could actually fit. Even so, the gap is clear. The plan on file uses less of the parcel's allowed density, and only the most limited housing type R-3 permits.
Thirteen Houses Facing First Avenue
Builder Todd Bates filed the concept in early August under the name "The Surf Residential." The drawing shows two rows of lots, most around 5,500 square feet, with a private drive between them. Each of the 13 homes would have its own pool, on lots at least 50 feet wide. The homes would run from about 1,400 to 1,800 square feet.
How people get in is what changes the feel of the block most. Under the concept, the enclave would be reached from First Avenue, the street one block west of South Fletcher that runs parallel to it behind the current Surf buildings. For seven decades this frontage faced the ocean across Fletcher, with a motel office, a bar and a deck that anyone could walk into. As drawn, the new lots would line a private drive, with the way in from a quieter residential street.
The house sizes matter too. Homes of 1,400 to 1,800 square feet on lots of about 5,500 square feet, set along a shared private drive, put the plan closer to a pocket neighborhood than a row of large beach houses.
Where the Review Stands
The concept went to the city's Technical Review Committee on Thursday, Aug. 13, 2026, at 10 a.m. It was listed as a "First Step Review." The Island Brief described that as a sit-down with city departments about what a project would need, not an approval. It also reported that nothing had been permitted and nothing was coming down yet.
Here is the order of events so far:
- 2016: FLANSOUTH LLC buys the 1.86-acre parcel for a recorded $1,662,000.
- Early August 2026: Todd Bates files "The Surf Residential" concept with the city.
- Aug. 12, 2026: The Surf announces its closing on Facebook.
- Aug. 13, 2026: The concept goes to the Technical Review Committee as a First Step Review.
- Sept. 14, 2026: The Times-Union reports that the restaurant and motel will both close.
- Sept. 20, 2026: The closing date the owners set.
No demolition date has been announced, and no later public hearing on the project has been reported. A first-step concept is the stage where a site's shape is most likely to change. The lot count, the drive layout and the First Avenue access could all look different by the time the plan comes back to the city. Anyone who wants to follow it can watch the agenda pages on the City of Fernandina Beach website for "The Surf Residential."
This is general information about a public filing and the city's zoning code, not legal advice. Anyone weighing what R-3 rules mean for their own property should confirm it with the city's planning staff or a land-use attorney.
The Rest of South Fletcher
The Surf's closing does not leave this end of Fletcher without a place to meet. Farther down the same avenue, at 3381 S. Fletcher Ave., two locally owned businesses announced a joint venture, Sand, Sage & Soul Gathering House. According to the News-Leader, Island Florals owner Russell Daniels is partnering with Sand and Sage owners Jill Vozza and Rich Yaworski. The venue was set to open on Labor Day, Sept. 7.
With Salt Life Food Shack at Main Beach Park and a florist-led gathering house down the road, South Fletcher's public spaces are drifting toward smaller, more specific rooms. The large, all-purpose beach bar that held this corner since the late 1950s is gone from that mix. The land under it is moving toward housing at a scale well below what its zoning permits.
If you own near The Surf's block, or have a stake in what happens along South Fletcher and First Avenue, I'm glad to walk through what a 13-home concept could mean for the street, and to keep an eye on the filing as it moves through city review. Daniel Hulett | Let's Connect.