For more than half a century, buying shrimp downtown worked the same way. You walked to the red shack beside the public boat ramp at the foot of Ash Street, bought seafood or bait at Atlantic Seafood, and watched the pelicans gather on the dock for the fish scraps tossed from the back. Amelia Island Living described the building as one of the most familiar sights at Fernandina Harbor Marina and said three generations of residents and repeat visitors knew it.
That counter is gone, and it is gone just as the local white shrimp season is underway. The week before Thanksgiving is a good time to cook with shrimp caught off this coast. Buying it now takes a little more planning than it once did, because the town that calls itself the birthplace of the modern shrimping industry no longer has a seafood counter at the water downtown.
The Last Season at the Boat Ramp
Atlantic Seafood Bait & Tackle closed for good in August 2025. The city owned the building, which was built in 1963, and the business had leased it on a lease that ran to 2028. The tenant asked to end it three years early, and the city agreed without a penalty because the change fit its plans for the riverfront. In September 2025 the building was declared a public safety risk. The city fenced it in October, and a "Notice of Dangerous Building" dated Oct. 9 went up on the front door.
On Nov. 20, 2025, all five members of the Historic District Council voted to approve the demolition without conditions. The building came down on Feb. 3, 2026, and by the end of that week only a pile of broken concrete was left beside the ramp.
At the HDC meeting, Deputy City Manager Jeremiah Glisson said the city planned short-term "soft" improvements for the north end of the waterfront park on that spot, with more permanent shoreline work around the boat ramp three to five years out, according to Amelia Island Living's report. He also said the city had talked with the museum and some local artists about saving boards from the building's exterior. The site is part of a larger rebuild of the downtown waterfront that also includes the marina overhaul.
What the Boats Are Bringing In Now
A 2026 study of Lowcountry shrimping published in Fisheries Research describes white shrimp as a spring and fall fishery and brown shrimp as mostly a summer one. Shrimpers interviewed for the study said Florida's white shrimp season usually runs from late fall into early spring. The same study puts the arrival of roe white shrimp off Georgia and northeast Florida in March or April. In recent years, brown shrimp have generally been around from late May through July, though timing and numbers change from year to year.
That puts the holiday weeks inside white shrimp season. If you only eat local shrimp at the Shrimp Festival in May, you are eating it in the gap between seasons.
There is still plenty of shrimp coming into the county. A Northeast Florida Regional Council market study recorded 608,637 pounds of shrimp landed in Nassau County in 2024, up from 497,068 pounds in 2023. The study counts landings by where the shrimp were brought ashore, not where they were caught. The harder part is finding someone who sells that catch to the public.
Why a "Local" Label Doesn't Settle It
This March, News4JAX reported on a study SeaD Consulting did for the Southern Shrimp Alliance. Researchers ordered shrimp at 44 restaurants and seafood markets across greater Jacksonville, picked at random, and tested what they were served. Fourteen dishes were confirmed as U.S. wild-caught and 30 were imported or farm-raised. At 25 of the businesses, imported shrimp had been explicitly sold as local, Mayport or American wild-caught. The visits took place March 6 through 8, 2026.
The pattern holds beyond Jacksonville. The Southern Shrimp Alliance's full report covers eight states and dishes sampled between November 2024 and May 2025. It counted 217 inauthentic dishes, 111 that were authentic U.S. wild-caught and 4 imported dishes that were labeled correctly.
The fisheries research explains why imports end up on the plate. The NEFRC study names cheaper farm-raised imports, fuel and maintenance costs, and weaker demand as the reasons some Northeast Florida shrimpers have tied up their boats. The Lowcountry study found that inflation-adjusted dockside shrimp prices in Georgia and South Carolina dropped from $2.51 a pound in 2004 to $1.53 in 2024. In a June 2025 News4JAX story on Fernandina's shrimping history, boatbuilder Nick Deonas said the area has no fish house or packing house to take in and process a catch, and no fuel or ice docks. In the same story, shrimper Michael Adams said imported shrimp were taking over.
In practice, that means you should ask whoever is selling the shrimp where it was landed and which boat brought it in. "Local" printed on a menu is not enough.
Where Wild Shrimp Is Sold Near the Island
On the island, start at the Fernandina Beach Market Place, the Saturday market on North Seventh Street that runs from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. all year. Its website lists wild-caught shrimp among the weekly offerings. For years, the market's vendor roster has included Chesser Seafood with "fresh, local, wild caught shrimp." The market's profile of Eddie and Debbie Chesser says they run a shrimp boat and sell what they catch at the Saturday market. If you're planning a holiday menu, stop by on Saturday morning and ask which boat this week's shrimp came off.
The closest counters with a recent record of genuine wild shrimp are farther south, at Mayport. Safe Harbor Seafood Market is at 4378 Ocean St., and its market page says you can watch boats unload seafood straight into the building. The Florida Department of Agriculture's seafood market directory lists Mayport C & C Fisheries at 36 W. Sixth St. in Atlantic Beach. Both Mayport C & C Fisheries Seafood Market and Safe Harbor Seafood Restaurant were among the 14 businesses that News4JAX named as accurately serving American wild-caught shrimp in the March testing. That list also included Singleton's Seafood Shack, Beachside Seafood, Marker 32 and New Berlin Fish House & Oyster Bar. If you're already in Jacksonville Beach or Atlantic Beach for the day, it's easy to add a stop at one of these markets.
The Shrimp Festival is another place to learn the names of the shrimpers behind local catch. The 2026 festival ran May 1 through 3, and its food vendors got their local wild-caught shrimp from H&S Shrimp and Adams Shrimp.
What the Waterfront May Look Like Next
The NEFRC study's recommendations speak directly to the labeling problem. It proposes a regional shrimpers' agricultural cooperative and a registered logo or trademark so shoppers can tell which shrimp was caught locally. The regional council presented the results and recommendations on May 2, 2025.
Meanwhile, the industry's best-known landmark has moved to a new spot downtown. By the end of March 2026, the shrimping industry monument had been relocated from near the old Brett's Waterway Cafe site to the new Amelia River Waterfront Park, a short walk south on Front Street. That is the same park now hosting downtown's community holiday nights, so if you're downtown for one of those evenings this season, the monument is right there.
The old Atlantic Seafood parcel at the boat ramp is set for the city's interim park improvements and, later, its shoreline work. The boats are still going out, and the white shrimp they're bringing in this season stay in season from now into early spring.
Daniel Hulett grew up on Florida's First Coast and spent 15 years as a Firefighter Engineer and Paramedic with the Fernandina Beach Fire Department. If you're settling into the island and want to know which corners of the working waterfront are still worth seeking out, or which part of Amelia Island fits the way you like to spend a Saturday morning, Let's Connect.